2026

The Tingley Pie & Ice Cream Social was held Sunday, August 24th 2025.


Vanilla winners


Anything Goes winners

6th Annual Hoover Angus Homemade Ice Cream Contest - $2500 in Prize Money was awarded

Vanilla category:
1st: Ann Iannotta
2nd: Jenifer Johnson
3rd: Ann Iannotta
4th: Tony Mercer
5th: Ann Iannotta

Anything Goes category:
1st: Becky Johnson - Chocolate Fudge Brownie
2nd: Joe Hynek - Strawberry
3rd: Julia Wideman - Angel Funfetti
4th: Mandy Groskruger - Strawberry Buttermilk
5th: Wendy Creveling - Maple Cinnamon
6th: John Overholtzer - Peanut Butter
7th: Jenifer Johnson - Cherry
8th: Erin & Christian Overholtzer - Pumpkin Spice Cream
9th: John Overholtzer - Chocolate
10th: Becky Johnson - Lemon Blueberry Swirl

Jenny Tull Memorial Pie Contest - $1000 in Prize Money was awarded


Pie winners

One Crust Pie Winners
1st Place: Robin Tarbell-Thomas - Peanut Butter
2nd Place: Becky Johnson - Cherry Crumb
3rd Place: Macy Jarred - Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan
4th Place: Mikayla Wilson - Pumpkin
5th Place: Molly Thomas - Maple Pecan

Two Crust Pie Winners
1st Place: Melinda Weeda - Sugar-free Apple
2nd Place: Carol Ann Weeda - Cherry
3rd Place: Melinda Weeda - Cherry
4th Place: Janet Wasteney - Peach
5th Place: Nancy Jarred - Cherry Berry Jumble

 

Photos From the Event
Flag over Main St YL-37 Helicopter
Patriot Guard Riders Zounds delights children
Foam Party People go through the ice cream line


 

Ice Cream Contest Rules

1. All ice cream is to be made in a crank or electric ice cream freezer.
2. No commercial mixes may be used. Entries must be made from scratch.
3. There will be two classes Vanilla and Anything Goes (you may enter both).
4. Entries will be judged on flavor, texture, appearance & originality (for anything goes).
5. Enter ice cream by 3:30 p.m. on Sunday, August 30 at Tingley Memorial Park (west side).
6. Bring your ice cream in a cooler packed with salt & ice or dry ice to keep it below freezing until judging begins!
Ice alone does not prevent your ice cream from melting which will affect the appearance being judged! To avoid runny ice creams, we recommend ice creams be churned and frozen in the deep freeze before being brought to the contest, or if freshly churned, be packed on ice with alternating layers of ice and salt.
7. We ask that contestants dip their ice cream to the public beginning at 5:00 p.m.
    Please bring your own dipper. Bowls & spoons provided.
8. Call Landi Livingston with questions: 641-344-7684


BIGGER Payouts for 2026!!

Prize Money for Anything Goes Category
1st Place - $500
2nd Place - $400
3rd Place - $300
4th Place - $200
5th Place - $100
6th-10th Places - $50

Prize Money for Vanilla Category
1st Place - $250
2nd Place - $200
3rd Place - $150
4th Place - $100
5th Place - $50

Pie Contest Rules

1. All pies must be homemade (no purchased pies).
2. Categories include single crust and double crust.
3. Please bring entry in disposable pie plate.
4. A contestant may enter as many pies as desired.
5. No pre-registration required - arrive with your pie to be judged.
6. Entries will be judged on taste, crust and overall appearance.
7. Please do NOT bring your pie directly from the oven!
Pies should be entered at a temperature where the judges can immediately sample your entry!
8. Enter pie between 3:00-3:15 p.m. on Sunday, August 30 at the Tingley Community Building
9. Call Joyce Frost with questions: 641-344-4936
10. Contestants are welcome to serve their pie!

Prize Money for Single Crust Category
1st Place - $150
2nd Place - $125
3rd Place - $100
4th Place - $75
5th Place - $50

Prize Money for Double Crust Category
1st Place - $150
2nd Place - $125
3rd Place - $100
4th Place - $75
5th Place - $50

 

 

Results from previous years

6th Annual Ice Cream Social - 2025
5th Annual Ice Cream Social - 2024
4th Annual Ice Cream Social - 2023
3rd Annual Ice Cream Social - 2022
2nd Annual Ice Cream Social - 2021
1st Annual Ice Cream Social - 2020